Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.
- MCI have been doing business with Bantelman Insurance for almost 18 years. I...Mike C., Olean, New York
“I have been doing business with Bantelman Insurance for almost 18 years. I moved out of the area, but continue to keep all of my business with them. Every interaction has always been efficient and professional.”
- KHI have been with Bantleman insurance for auto and home for several years! They...Kim H., Olean, New York
“I have been with Bantleman insurance for auto and home for several years! They are always very helpful when I call and get me the best deals for my insurance!”
- DPI had the opportunity to work with Joe and his team as clients, and I have been...David P., Olean, New York
“I had the opportunity to work with Joe and his team as clients, and I have been extremely impressed with their professionalism and positive attitude. Great people to work with.”
Always take care of everything and make buying insurance easy and affordable.Jeff M., Olean, New York- ...made my switch from my old policy easy and fast!Aaryn C., Olean, New York
“Jillana not only saved me a ton of money, but she also made my switch from my old policy easy and fast! Thank you, Jillana and thank you, Bantelman & Bantelman!”
- Fast friendly service, and they always have the best ratesKim D., Olean, New York
- I have been a satisfied customer...Amber D., Olean, New York
“I have been a satisfied customer for over a year now and I highly recommend stopping in for a quote.”
- ...had the best price I could find.
“I had a great experience with Jillana and they also had the best price I could find.”
- Definitely recommend them.Wiley M., Olean, New York
“Jillana was awesome to work with, I priced out 3 companies and Erie was the best. But Jillana went above and beyond and took care of my boat, cars, house, and saved money all the way around. Definitely recommend them.”
- She is saving me a Ton of money as well.Amanda R., Olean, New York
“Jillana was amazing to work with. Due to my schedule at work I wasnt able to make it in, but she made sure to help me over phone. She is saving me a Ton of money as well.. She is right on top of all the changes I have thrown her way.. thanks for all your help!.”
- NBNicole B., Olean, New York
“Mary Anne was amazing to work with! She made switching our auto and homeowners insurance seamless.
She’s incredibly knowledgeable, but what stood out most was how much she genuinely cares about the people she’s helping. You can tell she really values doing right by people, not just through great service, but by building real relationships and being genuinely trustworthy.”
- SHShannon H., Olean, New York
- MRMia R., Olean, New York
- JSjordan s., Olean, New York
“They were extremely helpful getting my business up and running! I couldn’t ask for a better group of people! Thanks again for all you guys have done for myself and my company!”
- Fred R., Olean, New York
“We love doing business with local people that you run into at the grocery store. The combination of Erie Insurance and the Bantleman Agency is like the perfect match. We recently had an accident and the service we received from both our Agent, Maryann Zitnik, and the claims agent from Erie Insurance was absolutely flawless. I appreciated the quick reaction from the agency and the genuine care they had for the well-being of my wife and children. These people are surely some of the best the Olean area has to offer!”
